Seinfeld
Rains on Puerto Rican Day Parade
by
WILLIAM SANTIAGO
1998 Latino Link
SAN
FRANCISCO, May 11, 1998 - I'll be watching Thursday night, applauding
Seinfeld's stellar run. And I'd never want to rain on his parade. However,
my comments will hardly constitute a drizzle. So let me go ahead and
mention the parade, the Puerto Rican Day parade around which the show's
second to last episode revolved.
Predictable
indignation among Puerto Ricans after the show aired, just as predictably
prompted shrugs and rolling of eyes from everyone else. Few could see
the umbrage taken by Puerto Ricans as anything else than a knee-jerk
reaction by an overly sensitive minority that can't take a joke.
There's
a bit more to it than that.
Consider:
"Seinfeld," television's highest rated gold mine, will depart
Thursday night with enough people watching for a commercial during the
farewell episode to command astronomical fees equivalent to that of
a half-time spot during the Super Bowl. The hyperbolic count down has
had the nation similarly glued to the tube.
Now
here comes the second to last show, the penultimate half hour. And there's
Jerry stuck in traffic in the middle of the Puerto Rican Day parade.
Beautiful. Possibly the only aspect of the Puerto Rican people that
hasn't been exploited by this country is the extraordinary humor of
their situation. Surely, "Seinfeld" will have a field day,
I thought, and sat back for some quality laughs.
Instead,
the script resorted to cheap laughs, and not many at that. Agonizingly
below the standards of comedy writing that made the show a success,
this episode took the easy way out and fell flat. In the shallowest
of caricatures and deathly stale gags, Puerto Ricans were depicted as
loud, grease-headed, criminally prone hot heads with what sounded like
poorly approximated Italian accents.
O.K.
we're loud. Sure, a bit hot headed. And if you happen to set the Puerto
Rican flag on fire during the parade, as Kramer did in this episode,
your life may very well have been in jeopardy. However the treatment
of the situation was low grade. Not only did it entrench unfortunate
stereotypes, I've heard better lines written for Eddie, the canine foil
on ''Frasier.''
For
the first time I was truly disappointed in Jerry Seinfeld, a man whose
exceptional work on stage I've admired ever since first catching his
stand up act at the original Caroline's Comedy Club on Eighth Avenue
in New York City long before he ever had a television show. Yet there
I sat, last Thursday night, grudgingly muttering, ''I can’t believe
it, Seinfeld, a hack."
Certainly
the episode suffered for the fumble of a great opportunity for humor.
But it didn't suffer for it nearly as much as the Puerto Ricans. When
you are depicted so rarely in mass media, each one of those occasions
matters that much more. When a show the kind of exposure that "Seinfeld"
delivers, delivers nothing but a regurgitated, unflattering image of
your people, it's hard to swallow benignly.
Note
that in the episode previous to this one, the plot involved Seinfeld
becoming indignant when a friend of his converts to Judaism. Jerry concludes,
incensed, that his friend has converted only to enjoy the privileges
of Jewish humor. "He's in it just for the jokes!" Jerry wails,
quite offended that his proud heritage should be appropriated on such
a superficial basis.
Then
the following week, in front of the eyes of millions of viewers, Puerto
Ricans are used merely as the butt of some lazily constructed lowest-common-denominator
cracks. And we had no opportunity on the show to utter a retort, humorous
otherwise, in our defense.
Puerto
Rico marks 100 years under American colonial rule this year. While Israel
celebrates its 50th anniversary as an American-backed independent state.
And
it's precisely the kind of persistent American indifference toward Puerto
Ricans, exemplified by their lamentable cameo in Seinfeld's series,
that stands as one of the main hurdles to improving their social stagnation,
both on the island and the mainland.
America
is a country where image rules in an age where image has never been
more instantaneously malleable. The mass-media image of Puerto Ricans
hasn't been updated since we last saw Natalie Wood screaming, "Chino!
Come get me Chino!" in "West Side Story."
Doubtless
its time to update that image. And no, it's not up to Jerry Seinfeld.
It's up to us to define our own image, to represent Puerto Ricans with
full respect for, and in full context of, who we are in three, pander-free,
dimensions.
Its
time we delivered our own television show about us for prime time. I'll
personally take up the challenge.
Meantime,
it is important to understand this. Although, the “Seinfeld”
show may claim to be a show “about nothing,” the clamor
that rose from the Puerto Rican community over their careless depiction
in such a television phenomenon, during its widely watched home stretch,
was not.